Stroke of the Pen: What ag lenders fear most, and why produce feels it first

At the ag bankers conference, the word of the week was uncertainty. In fresh produce, it lands faster and with less cushion.

Christian Kelly
November 16, 2026

Share This Article:

6 minute read

Best/Adobe Stock

I spent the first week of November at the American Bankers Association’s ag bankers conference, listening to economists, lenders, and regulators talk about where farm credit is headed. If you’d given me a nickel every time someone said “uncertainty,” I could have paid for the trip.

Trey Malone, an agricultural economist at Purdue University, gave that feeling a name which stuck with the room: stroke-of-the-pen risk. The idea is simple: the rules a borrower plans around can change overnight, with no warning and no history to model it from. And he doesn’t think it’s going away.

I came home convinced produce is where this matters most, and where lenders are watching least.

Risk You Can Price, Uncertainty You Can’t

Malone drew a line I keep coming back to: risk is something you can put odds on. You can model a bad harvest or a price swing. Uncertainty is what you can’t put odds on, and by the measures he showed, trade policy uncertainty is running more than 20 times its 1985 to 2015 average.

His advice was not to build a better forecast. When the ground shifts under the model, the model doesn’t save you. Spend less time on the headlines and more time on how they flow through your own book.

Dave Kohl, professor emeritus at Virginia Tech, then took the room on a walk around the world: China, Brazil, Europe. He ended up back home. His view is that agriculture will increasingly compete in regional blocs, and the bloc that matters most for U.S. agriculture is North America.

Other panelists agreed that Canada and Mexico remain among our most important partners. Kohl added a caution that applies to any trading relationship: trust, once damaged, takes a long time to rebuild.

When trade rules change, a grain elevator can store and wait. A truckload of tomatoes can’t.

Produce Already Lives in That World

Here is what struck me: for most of the room, a North American trade bloc is a strategy question. For produce, it’s this week’s loads.

A large share of the fresh fruits and vegetables Americans eat in winter crosses the southern border, and Canadian greenhouses help fill shelves year-round.

When trade rules change, a grain elevator can store and wait. A truckload of tomatoes can’t. When a new cost shows up at the border, importers, distributors, and retailers have days, not seasons, to decide who absorbs it.

Fresh produce barely came up on stage. This isn’t a criticism. The room thinks in corn, cattle, dairy, and land. But many of those banks lend to a packer, a distributor, a foodservice company, or a refrigerated carrier, and that exposure doesn’t always carry a produce label.

The Shock Absorber Produce Doesn’t Have

Malone’s most pointed advice was to rerun your top operating lines without government payments. He estimated about $140 billion in ad hoc payments have reached the farm economy since 2018, swinging by $10 to $20 billion from one year to the next.

Kohl put government payments at roughly 30 percent of net farm income and called that unsustainable. The economic outlook panel noted that most of the aid has gone to the grain complex.

Produce has mostly lived outside that safety net, so a stress test looks different here. The cushion isn’t a check from Washington; it’s the buyer paying on time. When a duty, a border delay, or a fuel spike squeezes a thin margin, the strain shows up first in how fast companies pay each other.

In produce, the earliest tell is payment pace.

Translating the Playbook to Produce

Malone closed with five recommendations for lenders and each one translates well to a produce book.

Tag each borrower by policy exposure. For produce, this means which way the product moves. An importer of Mexican product and a grower selling into export markets can face opposite shocks from the same headline.

Find the debt outside your file. Malone shared survey work showing 7 in 10 commercial farmers finance machinery through a dealer, not a bank. Kohl warned about split lines of credit and merchant credit. In produce, the biggest obligation you may not see is what your borrower owes its own suppliers, and under PACA those unpaid suppliers can stand ahead of your lien.

Watch what moves first. Renewals lead and defaults lag. Malone cited a survey in which 27 of 100 Midwest ag lenders reported more renewals and extensions than a year ago, against only 3 reporting fewer. In produce, the earliest tell is payment pace: a borrower paying its growers a little later each month, or a key buyer slowing down.

Name the kind of uncertainty. If plans go stale every month, shorten your review cycle, because a quarterly review can’t keep up with a product that spoils in a week.

If the trade is split on how to respond, underwrite each borrower on its own, since two importers of the same commodity may handle the same duty very differently. And when everyone says, “wait and see,” run the scenario. “I don’t know” is a signal, not a nonanswer.

A borrower holding off on a decision is telling you something, find out what.

Ask why they’re waiting. A borrower holding off on a decision is telling you something, find out what.

The Front Line Knows First

Kohl told the room that shoeshine stands and truckers can show where the economy is headed six to nine months before the data does. His lesson for bankers: stay close to the front line.

In produce, the front line is the trade itself, in how companies pay each other load by load. The industry has been recording that behavior for 125 years. Nobody can forecast the next stroke of the pen, but you can know, before it lands, which of your borrowers are closest to it.

Christian Kelly is head of Financial Services at Blue Book.

nn-cta-image (1)

News you need.

Join Blue Book today!

Get access to all the news and analysis you need to make the right decision --- delivered to your inbox.

MEMBERSHIP BENEFITS

It’s not what you know,
it’s who you know.
Luckily, you know us

Subscribe to our newsletter